Kadrey V Meta, Case No. 23-cv-03417-VC, 06/25/2025

First two paragraphs of desicion by US District Judge Vince Chhabria:

 

Companies are presently racing to develop generative artificial intelligence models—
software products that are capable of generating text, images, videos, or sound based on
materials they’ve previously been “trained” on. Because the performance of a generative AI
model depends on the amount and quality of data it absorbs as part of its training, companies
have been unable to resist the temptation to feed copyright-protected materials into their
models—without getting permission from the copyright holders or paying them for the right to
use their works for this purpose. This case presents the question whether such conduct is illegal.


Although the devil is in the details, in most cases the answer will likely be yes. What
copyright law cares about, above all else, is preserving the incentive for human beings to create
artistic and scientific works. Therefore, it is generally illegal to copy protected works without
permission. And the doctrine of “fair use,” which provides a defense to certain claims of
copyright infringement, typically doesn’t apply to copying that will significantly diminish the
ability of copyright holders to make money from their works (thus significantly diminishing the
incentive to create in the future). Generative AI has the potential to flood the market with endles
amounts of images, songs, articles, books, and more. People can prompt generative AI models to
produce these outputs using a tiny fraction of the time and creativity that would otherwise be
required. So by training generative AI models with copyrighted works, companies are creating
something that often will dramatically undermine the market for those works, and thus
dramatically undermine the incentive for human beings to create things the old-fashioned way.